New Delhi, July 20 — The Supreme Court on Monday said it would direct the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) to implement the Orissa High Court's ruling requiring an explicit "opt-out" option in the consent form for generation of APAAR (Automated Permanent Academic Account Registry) IDs.

A Bench headed by Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant, and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana, indicated that appropriate directions would be passed to ensure that the APAAR scheme remains voluntary and that parental consent forms clearly provide an option to refuse consent.

"We will direct CBSE to implement this judgment on a pan-India basis... as the (Orissa) High Court order has been accepted. We are directing CBSE to examine the issues as well," the CJI Kant-led Bench observed during the hearing.

The apex court also clarified that CBSE circulars would remain subject to the prevailing law, including the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023, and said the scheme would have to be implemented in accordance with the existing legal framework.

The apex court was hearing a writ petition filed by the parents of four students challenging the constitutional validity of the APAAR ID scheme and the CBSE's decision to require APAAR IDs for Board examination registration.

Appearing for the petitioners, senior advocate Indira Jaising contended that although the government describes APAAR as a voluntary scheme, it is linked to Aadhaar and, in practice, compels students to obtain Aadhaar in order to secure an APAAR ID.

Arguing that the requirement effectively makes Aadhaar a precondition for education, Jaising submitted, "Right to education is not a targeted service. The right to education is a Constitutional right. Therefore, asking a child to get an Aadhaar and an APAAR for being sent up to exams is against the Constitution."

The petition also sought strict compliance with the DPDP Act while obtaining parental consent for APAAR enrolment, raising concerns over the collection, storage and processing of children's personal data.

During the hearing, the CJ Kant-led Bench asked whether the Orissa High Court's judgment on the issue had been challenged.

On being informed that it had not, the apex court said CBSE would be directed to implement the High Court's directions across the country.

The petition challenges the APAAR framework as an Aadhaar-linked, lifelong academic identifier, alleging that it creates a centralised digital architecture capable of long-term tracking and profiling of students.

It contends that the scheme, though officially described as voluntary, is being implemented in a coercive manner by schools and education authorities, and that making APAAR mandatory for Board examination registration violates the fundamental rights to privacy, education and decisional autonomy under Articles 21 and 21A of the Constitution.

The plea further argues that the scheme lacks statutory backing, fails the tests of legality, necessity and proportionality laid down in the Supreme Court's landmark K.S. Puttaswamy privacy judgment, and infringes the "right to be forgotten" by creating a cradle-to-career digital identity linked with Aadhaar.

In December 2025, the Orissa High Court had held that while the authorities consistently maintained that the APAAR initiative was voluntary, the model consent form failed to reflect that position because it did not provide parents with an option to refuse consent at the outset.

A single-judge Bench of Justice Sashikanta Mishra observed that the absence of an express opt-out clause undermined the voluntary nature of the scheme, observing that "the model consent form does not appear to have been happily worded" and that, if APAAR was intended to remain voluntary, parents should be given a clear option "to refuse to submit their consent or to opt out of it entirely".

The High Court consequently directed the authorities to amend the model consent form to incorporate an opt-out/refusal clause.

Urvashi Dholakia returns to social Media after taking a detox break

Duleep Trophy: Gaikwad to lead star-studded West Zone squad; Mulani named vice-captain

SC upholds Delhi HC verdict quashing tender for passport, visa outsourcing at 4 Indian Missions

India need to dive deeper into their planning: Saba Karim outlines priorities after England ODI series

India approves first dengue vaccine QDENGA for people aged 4-60 years

Rohit Sharma 'shut everyone up' by hitting century at Lord’s, says Ravi Shastri

SC to direct CBSE to make APAAR ID opt-out option explicit, examine data protection concerns

Rajya Sabha: Newly-elected MPs including Pawan Khera, Sushmita Dev take oath

Nushrratt Bharuccha on winning best actress at NEXA Indian Streaming Academy Awards: ‘Recognition gives me a push’

IPS trainee accused of sexually harassing batchmate attempts suicide in Hyderabad

APEDA facilitates first export of frozen French fries from Uttarakhand to Iraq

Hanuman Beniwal extends support to NEET paper leak protest at Jantar Mantar, Parliament march

Virat was a master, he will remain one: Irfan Pathan

Cybercrime surge at alarming level in Bangladesh; women,children most affected

CM Vijay hails Tamil Nadu's chess legacy on World Chess day, pledges continuous support

Akhilesh Yadav himself wants Azam Khan ruined, claims UP Minister on SP chief's remarks about Jauhar University

Calcutta HC rejects Abhishek Banerjee’s plea seeking permission to travel abroad for medical treatment

How eVTOL aircraft could transform urban mobility in India

Tusshar Kapoor expresses excitement about working with Prakash Jha in 'Janadesh'

Pakistan faces fresh external risks despite FY26 current account improvement

Raj Babbar reveals daughter Juhi’s birth gave him a ‘purpose he never knew he needed’